MancBook Review: The Story of Manchester by Deborah Woodman

The trouble with attempting to tell the story of Manchester from the Roman occupation to the present day is that, for more than 1,000 of the intervening years, nothing much happened.

Even Roman Mamucium (or Mancunium), which lasted for around 300 years, didn’t really amount to very much. It was a minor fort in what we now call Castlefield around which the local Brigantes established a small settlement.

My favourite historian, the late A J P Taylor, wrote: “Manchester had a Roman foundation, though not worth lingering on about. Its only standing structural remains, the fragment of wall in a goods yard at the bottom of Deansgate, must rank as the least interesting Roman remain in England, which is setting a high standard.”

Deborah Woodman bravely begins her book with this quote, but claims Taylor doesn’t do justice to the beginning of Manchester’s story.

But bigging up General Agricola’s arrival with gems like “the garrison itself was built around AD79, ironically around the same time that Pompeii and Herculaneum were destroyed by the infamous eruption of Vesuvius in the Bay of Naples” serves only to diminish this obscure northern outpost. I suspect the ‘irony’ might have been lost on the plebeians of Pompeii as the volcanic ash rained down on them.

Wisely, however, she only devotes 18 pages to the occupation and many of those are taken up by describing various excavations and miscellaneous finds. Chester, York or Bath it ain’t.

So what happened when the Romans left? Not a lot. There’s a piece of romantic nonsense suggesting King Arthur’s foe Tarquin kept a castle in Manchester.

Lords of the manor came and went, some weavers arrived from Flanders and there was a minor skirmish between Roundheads and Cavaliers during the civil war as portrayed in the 19th Century painting by Ford Madox Brown and displayed in the town hall’s Great Hall.

But Brown’s series of paintings are themselves a construct, commissioned in a bid to give Manchester a history when mediaeval gothic revival was the height of fashion.

When Daniel Defoe came to Manchester in 1727, it was still ‘a meer village’ with no corporation, no MPs and its highest ranking magistrate was a constable. But it is the starting point of the real story of Manchester and it is a remarkable and unique one.

The contribution of Romans, Saxons, Normans, Plantagenets, Tudors and Stuarts towards the development of the world’s first industrial city in less than 150 years was effectively zero.

But that of an astonishingly inventive group of mainly local men in the latter years of the 18th Century was immense.

Richard Arkwright, John Kay, James Hargreaves and Samuel Crompton came up with the machines that took spinning and weaving out of the cottage and into factories, and James Brindley’s Bridgewater Canal brought the coal to keep them going.

Here Woodman’s narrative really takes off. It is concise and well-researched. But with each chapter featuring an introduction and a conclusion, her style is rather academic – perhaps not surprising, since her working background includes several universities.

She is strong on the unprecedented speed of Manchester’s growth, the resulting social conditions, and the radical politics – from Peterloo to the Chartists, the trade union movement and the campaign for women’s suffrage – that the class divide produced.

We see the origins of still familiar place names and the development of the city centre that continues to this day. One fascinating strand of her take on the city’s social history is the role of pubs and inns in the story – clearly an area of expertise, as Woodman completed her PhD on precisely this subject.

She also delivers a measured account of Manchester’s post-World War II decline. First the textile industry and then engineering all but collapsed, only for the city to reinvent itself as a post-industrial cultural hub – the penultimate chapter is called The Madchester Years.

The Story of Manchester by Deborah Woodman is published by The History Press, £16.99


Read more

Got a story worth sharing?

What’s the story? We are all ears when it comes to positive news and inspiring stories. You can send story ideas to [email protected]

Manchester is a successful city, but there are many people that suffer. The I Love MCR Foundation helps raise vital funds to help improve the lives and prospects of people across Greater Manchester – and we can’t do it without your help. So please donate or fundraise what you can because investing in your local community to help it thrive can be a massively rewarding experience.

This week